I dunno, it seemed fairly clear to me as well. I don't claim to be an expert, but I have had some interaction with 'fair use' through journalism and it's seriously not a free-for-all offer on a buffet.

I rather like Rose, Martha and Donna (but not Jack, whch makes me an oddity in fandom) and I try not to make judgements on people based on tastes varying. But I do get uncomfortable when a lot of vitrol is directed at any of the companions - goes when it's friends of mine doing it too.

Heh, no. I'd be very curious to hear why exactly the guy waved a sword around. Seriously, why a sword?!