Dubcon and noncon: A Rant
Sep. 26th, 2008 12:21 pmYou know what really, really bugs me of late, fanfic-wise?
A certain kind of dubcon and noncon that isn't at all labelled as such and the author doesn't even seem to be aware she/he is writing it, that's what.
Now, for various obvious reasons if you know, noncon and dubcon is just not going to appeal to me at all. But I know some authors who write it and are aware of what they're writing and it's a kink of theirs and - well, it will always squick me but domination fantasies are not that uncommon and hey, as long as it's labelled I can avoid it.
(So if you labelled your fic either of those in advance, I am not talking about you. Kay?)
But reading fanfic for a long time, I often come across fics - often with the adjective of "possessive" attached to the guy - where one of the pairing is very dominating and essentially forces the other to have sex. Heck, I've even read fics where the point is made even more painful by the sex actually being painful to the other, sometimes extremely so. (I don't refer here to the chick maybe getting a few bruises because they bumped into furniture or that sort of thing. It's more a level above rough sex and close to violence I had in mind.) It's not labelled as anything but smut, and is often sold as hot and yay and nothing disturning about how passive one partner is at all and hai, author, you've written dubious consent at best and rape at worst.
Granted, society feeds us a whole lot of shitty attitudes about women and sex and being passive and we're not always aware of how they lurk in our minds, but argh argh ARGH. Reading a fic that is essential rape without the author acknownledging it and seeming to find it the height of sexy just really, really disturbs me. Even more so when people comment on how hot and sexy it is and seems equally unaware. (And don't give me any 'oh but she discovered afterwards she really wanted it' bladida. Consent is giving before and not after for a damn good reason, and also, that treads dangerously close to 'but she really wanted it really' rape apology bullshit.) I've read things that literally make me want to throw up in Doctor Who fandom, BSG fandom, CSI fandom (some more than others) and... I don't know. Am I alone in spotting these and finding them disturbing?
This was your Friday evening rant.
A certain kind of dubcon and noncon that isn't at all labelled as such and the author doesn't even seem to be aware she/he is writing it, that's what.
Now, for various obvious reasons if you know, noncon and dubcon is just not going to appeal to me at all. But I know some authors who write it and are aware of what they're writing and it's a kink of theirs and - well, it will always squick me but domination fantasies are not that uncommon and hey, as long as it's labelled I can avoid it.
(So if you labelled your fic either of those in advance, I am not talking about you. Kay?)
But reading fanfic for a long time, I often come across fics - often with the adjective of "possessive" attached to the guy - where one of the pairing is very dominating and essentially forces the other to have sex. Heck, I've even read fics where the point is made even more painful by the sex actually being painful to the other, sometimes extremely so. (I don't refer here to the chick maybe getting a few bruises because they bumped into furniture or that sort of thing. It's more a level above rough sex and close to violence I had in mind.) It's not labelled as anything but smut, and is often sold as hot and yay and nothing disturning about how passive one partner is at all and hai, author, you've written dubious consent at best and rape at worst.
Granted, society feeds us a whole lot of shitty attitudes about women and sex and being passive and we're not always aware of how they lurk in our minds, but argh argh ARGH. Reading a fic that is essential rape without the author acknownledging it and seeming to find it the height of sexy just really, really disturbs me. Even more so when people comment on how hot and sexy it is and seems equally unaware. (And don't give me any 'oh but she discovered afterwards she really wanted it' bladida. Consent is giving before and not after for a damn good reason, and also, that treads dangerously close to 'but she really wanted it really' rape apology bullshit.) I've read things that literally make me want to throw up in Doctor Who fandom, BSG fandom, CSI fandom (some more than others) and... I don't know. Am I alone in spotting these and finding them disturbing?
This was your Friday evening rant.